Wednesday, September 29, 2010

ON THE EVE OF THE VERDICT

December 6, 1992: I remember I was cycling in the neighbourhood in the afternoon when the news came trickling in Babri Masjid had been demolished. As a school student, the words like Babri Masjid, karsevaks, Viswa Hindu Parishad were alien to me. I read them in newspaper. The same had taught me a little about Ram Mandir movement. But at that age it did not touch me. Later on the television we all watched those visuals of karsevaks hammering an old mosque getting on top of it. The riot followed. Bandhs crippled our life, examinations were postponed and there was Hinduttva bashing everywhere. I remember it took over a week to normalize the ‘bandh’ like situation.



18 years later, today we are all apprehensive of the reaction the Ayodhya title suit verdict will elicit from the Indian people. There is no doubt that the nation which is keeping its fingers crossed are carrying the baggage of the 1992 and, keeping that in mind, we are trying to diffuse our inner tension by saying the nation has moved forward, the young generation is not inclined to react violently, appealing to the people for peace and calm and there is scope of appealing before the apex court if one party is not satisfied with the judgment. We are reacting in the manner for the reason that the situation seems like the lull before the storm. As the actors involved in the 1992 incident and the resultant riots are all silent, not disclosing their cards on how they will ignite the people.



Amidst all these apprehension the big puzzle remains if, after almost two decades, the people will react in 1992-way after the jury is out, in whosever way the verdict goes. Many vouch for the ‘progressive young India’, who would apparently be not swayed away by the religious and communal sentiments, rather restrict themselves on social networking sites, blogs, and chatrooms voicing their opinions (remember the government has banned ‘bulk SMS’!) Still there are worries why the administration is not taking any chance. First, to my understanding, there is a latent inherent communal feeling among all of us and no one can deny this fact even if someone proclaims to be secular or atheist. Second, there are actors in the religious and political community which may try to incite the people to the benefit of their interest; thereby polarizing the nation once again. If both are exploited by any section of any religious communities, we are heading for a bad time.



Fortunately in 2010 there is no face of the politico-religious movement either from the Hindus or from the Muslims, unlike in those days of Babri demolition when LK Advani was leading Rathayatra, Ashok Singhal or Praveen Togadias of VHP/RSS were organizing Ram janmabhoomi movement. It is positive but has negative impact as well. It doesn’t require only a leader or a movement to turn people violent in such situation. It can go uncontrollable even if there is any leader (as the BJP claims what happened in Ayodhya in 1992 was not under the control of the leadership).



At the end of the day, it will be a test case for the Indian nation, how the political and religious leaders go beyond their petty interest and how the young India reacts to the Temple-Mosque issue after the verdict is pronounced. The fear is still the worst riot of the decade happens in Left-ruled Bengal’s Deganga, a small bloc in North 24 Parganas district!

Sunday, September 19, 2010

THE FIR

To


The Officer-in-charge

Salboni Police Station

West Midnapore

West Bengal 03-09-‘10





Sir,

At around 2:40pm on 03-09-’10 (Friday), we, Pranab Mandal and Amit Dutta of The Telegraph, Sambit Pal and Suraj Pandey of Times Now, Arnab Mukhopadhyaya, Sudip Guchhait and Amitava Ratha of Star Ananda, were proceeding towards Chandra from Pirakata in two cars (WB 20G 8864/Innova and WB 04D 4650/Scorpio) bearing stickers of Star Ananda and Times Now respectively, being driven by Subodh Roy and Mahesh Burman. As we reached near the Pirakata joint forces’ camp, we were checked at the check post and allowed to proceed after we identified ourselves.



As we moved about 2 kilometers from the joint forces’ camp on the same road, we were suddenly intercepted by a group of 15-20 persons who were armed with small arms tucked under their shirts/t-shirts, bamboo sticks, sticks and iron rods. They were in jeans –shirt, lungi, t-shirts, kurta, etc. one of them covered his face with ‘gamchha’ and wearing black t-shirt. They opened the doors of the cars and asked why we have come here. Before we could say anything they started threshing us, snatched our cameras and mobile phones. Despite telling them repeatedly that we were from media houses, they didn’t listen to us. Immediately started hitting us with iron rods, bamboo sticks and sticks. They smashed the cars’ wind screens, window glasses and backlights. They badly damaged our cars.



We were dragged out of the cars, thrashed to the ground, brutally beaten up. Pranab Mandal of Telegraph suffered fracture on his left arm (the fracture was detected later through X-ray in Midnapore town) and his arm started bleeding at the spot, Sambit Pal suffered injury on his left arm and fingers which are swollen. Amitava Ratha suffered injury on his left hand and there is suspected hairline fracture. Amitava Ratha also suffered injury on his lower right leg. Star Ananda cameraperson Sudip Guchhait also suffered injury on his left hand and neck. Suraj Pandey got hit by bamboo sticks on his back, Telegraph photographer Amit Dutta got hurt on his arms and neck. All of us suffered injuries while they were beating us up at the same spot.



These armed goons identified themselves as CPIM cadres. There were CPIM red flags all over the area, on trees, little shops, huts, etc. These CPIM goons while beating us abused us and kept saying in Bengali,

“ki re tora harmad der camp dekhte esechhis? Dekh, toder ki dekhai!”


“tora kothay chili jokhon amader kormira gramchhara chhilo? Jokhon amader meyeder darshon kora holo, tokhon asis ni ekhon amader camp dekhte esechhis?”


“ke toder pathiyeche? Mamata na shuvendu?”


“dekhachhi toder sob.”


“ nam siggiri gari theke. Ekhane keno esechhis?”


“toder hat kete fele rekhe debo.” “toder ekhane asar ki jogyota ache?”



After a while, they forced us to go back but halted our cars agains to force it back to the same sport. We were threaten that we would be killed and our bodies would be buried there itself. We were asked to sit in front of a little shop there. At that time two CPIM leaders named Madhusudan Mahato, (aprox age 50), Local Committee Secretary, Pirakata, CPIM, Jagannath Mahato (Aprox age 55-60), a local CPIM senior leader of Salboni area reached the spot and told us in threatening voice, “ekhane ki korte esechhen aapnara? Ekhane keu ase? Joutha bahinir camp theki ba apnader edike ke aste dilo? Mar khaben e. edike ki camp khujte esechhilen? Jak ekhon ja bolbo tai karun. Jemon bhabe bolbo temon bhabe jaben. Ekhan theke jaben na. mar khawai toh swabhabik.beshi barabari korben na. ekdom chupchap bosun.”



Then these two leaders called a cadre and told him to take our cars towards Satpati. As we requested them to allow us to go through the road we came from by the Pirakata camp of joint forces/ they prevented us and said, “ja bolchhi kor, noyto punte rekhe debo.” We were silenced. We requested them to return our cameras and mobile phones. After repeated requests, they have returned some mobile phones but seized three mobile phones (the numbers are 9433447231, 9830996089 and 9433096809)



They’ve returned the cameras abut one camera’s view finder was damaged. Then we were instructed to get into the cars and follow the motorbikes two of the CPIM cadres were riding. As we followed them through a ‘moram’ road, we saw a CPIM camp with CPIM flags all over , in a building which was equipped with a generator and bunkers. As we reached the main road (Pirakata to Bhadutala road) near Satpati, we were freed to go and they asked us not to stop anywhere.



Before we left the spot, we were offered money as compensation and bribe as Madhusudan Mahato and Jagannath Mahato threatened us ,”takata nin. Kichhu jeno ei niye lekhalikhi korben na.” we refused to take the money and left the place. We came directly to the Midnapore Medical College and Hospital to see the doctor at the emergency ward. After medical check up we came straight to lodge the complaint.



We are herby lodging the complaint with you to take legal action applying appropriate sections of law and by initiating a case against the above mentioned miscreants.



Thanking you,

Yours truly,



Sd/- Sambit Pal

Arnab Mukherjee

Suraj Pandey

Amitava Rath

Pranab Mandal

Amit Dutta

Sudip Guchhait